Teachers are invaluable – and it’s high time we make them see it.

Nothing beats first-hand experience when it comes to teaching. It doesn’t matter how many books you’ve read on teaching if you haven’t actually taught a single class in your life or if you haven’t been in one for ages. You don’t know what it’s like to be a teacher. I have recently decided to go back into teaching (January 2023) and it helped me reconnect with the pleasures and struggles of real-life teaching as opposed to as-seen-in-books-and-webinars teaching. Teaching is a beautiful job with all its intricacies and challenges and today I’d like to address teacher education as perceived by teachers and as perceived by other stakeholders.

Perhaps because I take on the role of teacher educator whenever the opportunity arises, I believe my algorithm has been trained to show me posts regarding the topic (mostly Instagram and LinkedIn) and for the past couple of months, I’ve read some six different articles on the topic from the perspective of non-teachers. What caught my attention in those articles was the fact that all of them addressed the issue from a somewhat top-down perspective. One of them asked, “How can we make sure teachers stay in the profession?” another “What can we do to increase teachers’ participation in CPD?” and what baffles me is that it seems that the underlying message here is that teachers are demotivated, quitters, weak, and uninterested in continuous professional development and growth – which is NOT true.

What all of these articles failed to analyze, perhaps because they were written for school administrators, business owners, or the general public – not teachers – is the fact that teachers are rarely paid what their qualifications and knowledge are worth and tend to transition into different jobs in education to try and make sure their skills and expertise are taken into account; their bank accounts as well.

It is shocking how much an English teacher needs to know nowadays to even be considered for a job. You have to have control of the language, a college degree (do notice how both of these involve a time and money investment) aside from active methodologies, the maker movement, gamification, PBL (both of them), CLIL, inclusion, differentiation, ODS, BNCC, SEL, 21st-century skills, Bloom’s Taxonomy of cognitive levels and the list goes on and on. And, alas, these professionals are expected to perform at the highest of standards while being paid R$26,37 on average in São Paulo (according to Glassdoor.com). How can one be motivated to stay in the profession and pursue CPD when you make just enough for a single meal with an hour’s work?

Oh, and not to mention employers who decide it is best for you that they withhold your worker’s rights because ‘they are too expensive’. Mind you, they are invaluable.

5 responses to “Teachers are invaluable – and it’s high time we make them see it.”

  1. Martin Hajek Avatar

    I completely agree with you. Many teachers have to work long hours, which often involves commuting to different locations, just to make ends meet. It’s not easy to pursue CPD when living paycheck to paycheck.

    I wonder if the increasing popularity of online learning will affect the situation in any way. I mean, it makes little sense for teachers based in Brazil to work for local language academies when they can get a better hourly rate working from home.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Richard Cowen Avatar
    Richard Cowen

    The unfortunate truth is that Tefl teaching has become part of the gig economy. I work at a prestigious school and nowadays only freelance contracts are available. In relative terms the school pays well but there is a lot of pressure on teachers to fully participate in CPD.
    No one would deny the necessity for teachers to constantly develop but like a piece of elastic the demands on teachers are being stretched. The more stretched, the more likely it will break. It’s unrealistic under gig economy conditions to expect teachers to embrace CPD. Their pay and worth is measured in hours taught not in how well qualified and up to date they are in their teaching methodologies and approaches. This results in an approach to education in which quantity is more important than quality and is another example of how education is simply another commodity in the capitalist system.
    I fear it will only get worse with teachers being exploited increasingly more. Only those fortunate enough to enjoy the privilege of a full time teaching contract will be able to properly indulge in CPD. Conditions will only improve when demand exceeds supply but with so many tefl teachers on the market that situation is unlikely to change in the near to middle future.

    Liked by 1 person

    1.  Avatar
      Anonymous

      Exactly my case.
      I almost invested in doing DELTA, but I realized that it would only end up being for for my own edification. Not that it’s not a good enough reason, but if I’m going to invest a couple of thousand into professional development, I might as well just learn how to do something else. The demand vastly exceeds the supply as it is, but that doesn’t necessarily create upward price pressure.

      Like

    2. ibasante Avatar

      Not to be contrary, but the focus is on the flawed products, too.

      Like

  3. Richard Cowen Avatar
    Richard Cowen

    The unfortunate truth is that Tefl teaching has become part of the gig economy. I work at a prestigious school and nowadays only freelance contracts are available. In relative terms the school pays well but there is a lot of pressure on teachers to fully participate in CPD.
    No one would deny the necessity for teachers to constantly develop but like a piece of elastic the demands on teachers are being stretched. The more stretched, the more likely it will break. It’s unrealistic under gig economy conditions to expect teachers to embrace CPD. Their pay and worth is measured in hours taught not in how well qualified and up to date they are in their teaching methodologies and approaches. This results in an approach to education in which quantity is more important than quality and is another example of how education is simply another commodity in the capitalist system.
    I fear it will only get worse with teachers being exploited increasingly more. Only those fortunate enough to enjoy the privilege of a full time teaching contract will be able to properly indulge in CPD. Conditions will only improve when demand exceeds supply but with so many tefl teachers on the market that situation is unlikely to change in the near to middle future. The firm establishment of online teaching will only exacerbate the situation.
    I’m coming towards the end of my tefl career and it has given me so much joy, mainly because I’ve been able to develop myself professionally but I would seriously have to question my desire to teach if I was starting out on this career for the reasons elaborated on above.

    Like

Leave a comment

I’m Bruno

Welcome to ELT in Brazil’s official website. Here you’ll find live and recorded courses for teachers on language and language teaching/learning, blog posts, and lesson ideas for your classes.

Let’s connect

bruno.albuquerque.elt@gmail.com